রবিবার, ২২ নভেম্বর ২০২৬, ০২:৩৬ পূর্বাহ্ন
*State’s Responsibility Is to Anticipate Danger, Not Merely React After It Occurs*
*— Professor M. A. Barnik*
In recent times, incidents of violence, attacks on government installations, arson, vandalism, and disturbing developments concerning law and order have occurred in various parts of the country. Some of these incidents have also raised questions about the capabilities of state institutions and the effectiveness of security arrangements. Such incidents cannot be viewed merely as isolated criminal activities; rather, they underscore the need to review the country’s security preparedness, intelligence operations, risk assessment mechanisms, and preventive capabilities.
One of the fundamental responsibilities of the state is to ensure the protection of citizens’ lives, property, security, and government institutions. Taking lawful action after a crime has been committed and bringing the perpetrators to justice are undoubtedly important. However, in a modern state, the concept of security cannot remain confined to reacting after an incident has occurred. The more effective philosophy of national security lies in identifying potential threats in advance, assessing their nature and magnitude, and taking timely preventive measures.
The question is whether the state will limit its responsibility to taking action after every crisis, or develop the capacity to identify potential dangers and address them before they escalate into a crisis. This question is particularly significant in the context of Bangladesh’s current security and administrative realities.
Prevention, Not Reaction, Is the Core Philosophy of Security
Whenever a police station is attacked, a government installation is set on fire, weapons are looted, or organised violence disrupts public life, state institutions naturally become active. Investigations are initiated, security is strengthened, efforts are made to identify and arrest the perpetrators, and various security forces are deployed to bring the situation under control. These measures are necessary and constitute an integral part of the state’s responsibilities.
However, one important question remains: Were there any warning signs before the incident took place? Had any intelligence information, changes in the local situation, organised activities, or indications of a possible attack come to the attention of the relevant authorities? If so, were appropriate preventive measures taken on the basis of that information?
The effectiveness of a security system cannot be adequately measured solely by how quickly forces were deployed after an incident, how many perpetrators were arrested, or how many cases were filed. An equally important measure of security capability is the extent to which potentially dangerous situations can be identified in advance and prevented from turning into violence. This is because the damage caused by an incident cannot always be reversed.
Effective Utilisation of Intelligence Information
Intelligence information is an extremely valuable asset in the field of national security. However, merely collecting information does not constitute the ultimate success of intelligence operations. True success lies in properly analysing the information collected, assessing potential threats, informing the relevant authorities in a timely manner, and effectively utilising that information to support necessary decisions.
Even when fragmented information is received from various sources, it may be difficult to understand the overall picture of a potential threat unless those pieces of information are analysed collectively. Unusual activities in one location, organised propaganda elsewhere, rising tensions in a particular area, or unusual interest in a specific installation may not appear particularly significant when considered separately. However, through proper analysis and the identification of links among these developments, it is possible to develop an advance understanding of potential threats.
In this regard, the professional competence of intelligence agencies, their analytical capabilities, information verification procedures, and effective communication with decision-making authorities are critically important. At the same time, the risks of making decisions based on rumours, misleading information, or politically motivated propaganda must also be taken into consideration. The true value of intelligence information is established only when it contributes to practical measures aimed at ensuring state security.
Risk Assessment and Institutional Coordination
Not all government installations face the same level of security risk. Risk assessments should be conducted by taking into account the importance and location of each installation, public gatherings, previous security conditions, and potential threats.
Security plans for police stations, prisons, armouries, important government offices, electricity and energy infrastructure, and communication systems need to be reviewed regularly. Security arrangements must also be adapted and improved in response to changing circumstances.
National security is not the sole responsibility of any one institution or security force. Information sharing, a clear division of responsibilities, and coordinated decision-making among intelligence agencies, the police, the administration, and relevant security institutions are essential. Even when intelligence information is available, a lack of coordination or delays in decision-making can undermine the effectiveness of the security system.
Therefore, it is necessary to ensure not merely formal communication, but also effective coordination, mutual trust, accountability, and the capacity to implement decisions promptly.
Learning from Failures and Utilising Technology
Simply assigning blame or taking disciplinary action following a security failure does not guarantee future security. The actual causes of failure must be identified. Whether the failure resulted from inadequate information, weaknesses in intelligence analysis, delays in decision-making, negligence in discharging responsibilities, or deficiencies in institutional coordination must be assessed objectively.
If lessons drawn from investigations are not used to improve security procedures, training, technology, and coordination mechanisms, similar failures may recur.
In today’s world, cybercrime, incitement through social media, digital propaganda, and the misuse of artificial intelligence are creating new security challenges. Technology makes it possible to collect and analyse information rapidly and monitor changing circumstances. However, technology can never replace professional judgement, field-level observation, and experience. An effective security system can be developed only through the integration of these capabilities.
At the same time, safeguarding the rule of law, human rights, citizens’ personal privacy, and fundamental freedoms remains an essential responsibility of the state.
Public Trust and the Capabilities of the State
One of the greatest strengths of national security is public confidence in state institutions. When citizens trust state institutions, cooperate with law enforcement agencies, and provide information responsibly, the effectiveness of the security system increases. Conversely, insecurity, rumours, panic, and a lack of confidence in institutions can intensify social instability.
Therefore, responsible communication with the public, dissemination of accurate information, prevention of rumours, and ensuring lawful conduct are essential. Citizens must have confidence that the state is alert, prepared, and fulfilling its responsibilities appropriately to protect their security.
The State Must Demonstrate Its Capacity to Address Crises
Although responding to threats is an essential responsibility in matters of national security, prevention is a more effective strategy. Priority must be given to identifying potential threats, analysing intelligence information, conducting risk assessments, formulating security plans, ensuring institutional coordination, and strengthening professional capabilities.
The strength of a state’s security system cannot be judged solely by how quickly it responds during a crisis. Rather, it should be assessed on the basis of the state’s preparedness and capacity to address threats before they develop into crises.
The security philosophy of a responsible state should be to identify potential dangers in advance, remain prepared to address crises, and build a safer future by learning from every failure.
State security becomes truly meaningful when the state does not have to awaken only after every disaster to protect its citizens; rather, it remains prepared in advance to fulfil its responsibilities.
*(The author, Professor M. A. Barnik, is a professional defence analyst and a keen observer of international geopolitical developments.)*